The Britney X Factor backlash begins

Back in March after the first unofficial confirmation surfaced that Britney Spears would become a judge on season two of the X Factor, I posted a list of pros and cons about her joining the fledgling show. One of the cons was the inevitable criticism the Queen B could subject herself to with such a daring return to the public eye — after all, before she became a zombified recluse, Britney was the media’s favorite punching bag.

The new season doesn’t hit TV screens until September, but it looks like the Britney backlash has already well and truly begun.

This week both Wendy Williams and Kathy Griffin devoted segments to Britney’s X Factor deal on their talk shows. On top of voicing their own respective opinions on the big move and sharing their love for Britney, both chatterboxes scrutinized photos of the songstress from the recent Fox Network press conference, labeling the Queen B messy and unstable, and only half-joking that she could fall apart at any moment. They also both zoomed in on a photo of one of Britney’s fingernails, which had been picked and chewed to the point of bleeding — a worrying sign of nerves and anxiety.

Wendy concluded her segment by warning Britney to hand back the $15 million dollar pay cheque and to go back into hiding, while Kathy and her cohorts were excited at the prospect of seeing Britney and the troubled Demi Lovato having a meltdown on TV.

It’s not just trashy talk show divas weighing in on Britney. The Hollywood Reporter has already consulted ‘Hollywood Crisis Experts’ to evaluate Godney’s chances of success, while CNN ran an article on the potential impact that the X Factor could have on her career.

“She walks around like a robot. People can’t relate to that,” Rolling Stone associate editor Andy Greene told CNN. “This could prove to be a whole new phase of her career. Britney 4.0.”

CNN were right on the money with their assessment of Spears, stating that the role on the X Factor is most likely more about Britney’s team rebuilding her public image than trying to score a hefty payday.

Britney’s not going to be able to compete with the Rihanna’s and Beyonce’s of the world much longer if her success continues to ride solely off her name and the nostalgic fondness that most twentysomethings have for her. In recent years her music has become more shallow and her creative input has dramatically decreased, she’s grown more detached from her fans and the public, and her performances have continued to get worse. It’s hard being a Britney fan these days when you don’t have any access to the best thing about Britney, which is Britney herself.

Whether she crashes and burns on X Factor or passes with flying colors, this has to be the best thing for her career right now. Either way, it’ll give Britney back some personality and a little edge, whether it’s “OMG BRITNEY IS A HOT MESS DID YOU SEE HER FORGET HER LINES LAST NIGHT?” or “OMG BRITNEY IS SO CUTE AND FUNNY JUST LIKE I REMEMBER HER!”.

It’s a little worrying that the media is already starting to act like it’s 2007 again by analyzing her mental health so vigorously and zooming in on photos of her fingernails to find any signs of self-destruction, but it’s about time Team Britney dealt with reality and released the Princess of Pop from her ivory tower once and for all.


This entry was posted on Friday, May 18th, 2012 at 11:40 pm and is filed under News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

  • SuckerPunch

    Haters going to hate.

    It was Britney’s idea to do it. She has to join Hollywood again sometime and she’s been present at Hollywood events for awhile now…and XFactor was her idea so  yeah
    She’ll do it, and people will deal!

  • Brittina2012

    The most annoying part of all of this is going to be the media creating the whole Bitney vs. Xtina thing. Especially since The Voice is coming back in the fall for a new revamped, revised season. It’s going to get rough. But regardless Brit Brit and Xtina are friends and no matter what the media says there is no bad blood.

  • iAmJayDO

    I’ve never been a fan of watching celebrities for their personalities. I’ve always liked them behind the scenes to add some mystery to who it is I’m watching. Leave me craving for more! I loved Lady Gaga because she was so wacky yet you never saw her anywhere. Now she’s every fuckin where and I can’t stand hearing one thing about her. Britney is a bit different though. For someone who’s been running so long, you never really get to KNOW her. She’s almost like Beyonce where you see small bits and pieces, but never the entire picture. I’m kind of interested in seeing what she’s going to deliever.

    PS: What’s up with Demi’s face in that picture….

  • DRB

    I don’t think any one cares about them and both of their careers are a shadow of what they used to be.

  • DiegoZicoB

    I feel like this will be make or break for Britney. It’s either going to show the world why they fell in love with her to begin with and wipe away any remnants of ‘unstable Britney’ they still have in their minds. Or it’s going to further confirm that she’s not ever going to be like her former self and will need the constant support and help of her handlers. 
    They’re taking a big risk putting her out there on such a large public scale again which is a huge vote of confidence in her abilities. 

    She may be riding on the nostalgia of her career but her popularity and interest in what she’s doing hasn’t waned, in fact its grown. That may be in part to there being such limited access to her, people want more of what they can’t have so its clearly worked to a degree but for how long remains to be seen.

    On the other hand though Britney has always received undue criticism, even during the golden years of her career, and she hasn’t even sat in that X Factor judge’s chair for a day yet so lets all just wait for episode one before we go shitting on her and her abilities.

  • DRB

    Britney shouldn’t be touring or making music, let alone exposing “herself” ever week. She doesn’t need to be in front of a camera so intimately. Articulate she is not, and she’s like a child who needs a bit of help. She should know performance but honestly, it doesn’t and I don’t think she has any musical advice worth my time.

  • DiegoZicoB

    No one cares about Britney yet this post is about how everyone has an opinion on Britney joining X Factor. Doesn’t make any sense, does it?

  • theprophetblog

    So true Diego!

    Even on that awful Kathy show after they said Britney is a trainwreck or whatever, they were all like “OMG I’M WATCHING THE SHOW NOW THOUGH I LOVE BRITNEY”.

    Everyone will watch X Factor now, whether it’s because they love britney, hate britney, or are just curious to see how she is now.

  • Corey

    This article is bullshit! As a longtime Britney fan, I am disgusted by anyone commenting on Spears right now who is not rooting for her success. Despite what that bitch has gone through in her life she still got the fuck back up dusted herself off and TRIED AGAIN to quote the legendary Aaliyah!  I will always ride for Britney b/c of haterzzzz like yourself, Kathy , CNN, Rolling Stone, and Wendy Hypocrite Williams (whom by the way PRAISED this decision a few weeks earlier) Britney has NEVER hid who she was, ever! We all know she has mental issues. So fucking what?! Who cares! Is that what we’re criticizing now? People on these reality shows can’t be nervous or have issues? Fuck, I thought most reality show s nowadays thrive off mentally fucked up ppl being trashy (Housewives franchise, BBW etc) But since its Britney fucking Spears everyone has a negative opinion alwayzzz throwing shade but still  using HER NAME to get “hits” or ratings like Rolling Stone (on their cover over 8 times!) or Prophet Blog. It is shameful how the media uses her name to get coverage only to hate on her. I’m sick of this! I WILL SUPPORT BRITNEY FOREVER!!!! FUCK THE MEDIA!!! This woman is a survivor! I LOVE her music & I respect her and most importantly I will continue to support her b/c of people hating on a clearly fragile human being who deserves to defended, regardless of the media! Britney, the real fans are ready. We love you.

  • theprophetblog

    Why are you including me? I didn’t say a bad thing about her in this post.

    I agree that it sucks how the media is always negative towards Britney, especially with stupid things (they don’t seem to help get out of this convervatorship but they’re happy to make fun of her mental health and appearance etc). The media always trashed Britney when she was still on top and they do it when she’s down too. As a longtime Britney fan I have had to witness it all and defend it in the past.

    But you are a prime example of one of her MANY deranged and deluded stans. Britney stans are every bit as bad, probably even worse, than Monsters and Bey stans. You people don’t care about her at all — you’re like parents who have gay children but it’s never spoken about. You glaze over anything remotely negative about her career etc even if it’s true. 

    Instead of being normal and rational and acknowledging that it’s not exactly the healthiest thing to be biting your finger until it’s bleeding (a textbook sign of anxiety) you just gloss over it and make excuses then go on a huge tirade abusing everyone, from top media outlets to me who just did a post talking about how the media might be starting to attack her again. You guys have no perception of reality when it comes to her, it’s extremely unhealthy and I see so many stans that I think have very unhealthy obsessions with their favorite stars. It’s sad and sick.

    You totally misinterpreted everything in this entire post and twisted into something completely deluded. Britney stans are just insane. They turn everything into a negative then accuse others of being the ones who do it. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dermot-O-Gorman/665377508 Dermot O Gorman

    jesus sounds like your her bff knowing everything that goes on…did brit tell you it was her idea lol

  • Somebody

    So….. I think it is stupid for everybody to comment on her FINGER NAILS BITE!!!! WTF PROPHET for real…… YOu say it is a sign of madness or whateva… I say SHE DID THIS UNTIL WE KNOW HER!!! All true Britney fans know that she is biting her nails. I do and sometimes they bleed, so Im insane now? GTFO! This is stupid. It is absolutely normal for her to be nervous…. Imagine u going there and being exposed to that level! I would EAT my finger, not just my nails…. I truly hope Britney is going to go out there and prove she is stable, funny and all BUT with the twist the media started by just the begining I feel like it is not going to be possible CUZ she is gonna be critisized about the way she talk, she sits and she poops! Just stop it!

  • Corey

    Its fine to disagree with my post but the fact remains that you’re not a real fan of Spears. You’re a fan of her legacy. I am a fan of the person, the music, and the story of Britney Spears in general. If that makes me deranged stan, I will gladly accept. However I will not tolerate any shade being thrown around before she even tapes her first ep for X Factor. If she is a mess then I will acknowledge it and move on like I have countless other times in her career (Vmas 2007, head shaving, etc) I just always felt as a supposed “fan” of Spears you understood how much she struggled to regain success after all she’s been through. You have written about her the past few years as if you’re over her and the lazy performances and lack of personality. My deluded ass would think it was time for you to STOP WRITING ABOUT HER THEN! But no, she brings in more readers for you so I guess shading her is OK by that standard. 

  • theprophetblog

    LOL I’ve bitten my nails lots of time (gross I know) and they never bleed.

    And there’s diff between biting your nails and biting your fingers, which is what Britney did.

    Not attacking Britney at all, just sayin’.

  • theprophetblog

    Um, if anything I’M the true fan of her as a person and everything about her. Everyone else just wants Britney wheeled around like a zoo animal and is perfectly content to let anything happen as long as Team Britney keeps releasing those shiny pop songs and sexy music videos.

    And hello, of course I say she has lazy performances and lack of personality in the public eye — it’s the TRUTH. I’m not going to gloss over it just because I love her. If I can drag everyone else for bad performances then why is Britney exempt? 

    You people can’t separate the pop star from the person.

    Most ‘fans’ are happy for anything to happen to Britney as long as the charade of her as a singer is still kept up. I’d be happy for her to retire from the public eye and never release music again if it meant she was happy and didn’t have to live under a conservatorship. Delivering bad performances, scripted interviews, and music she has no creative input into (my source: Femme Fatale album credits) only taints her name and makes people think that she’s some autotuned robot with no talent, when I know that she is more than that.

    And why would you move on from her when she was a ‘mess’? That’s not very fanworthy. There was a lot of build up and a lot of factors that went into her breakdown. It was the first time she got to experience true freedom but she was unable to manage her own life properly, which wasn’t her fault considering her history. SMH. See what I mean. You guys are happy to ignore anything negative because it interferes with the big glossy pop star you want to see, and then you go around trolling and attacking everyone else.

    Also, I’m not saying anything bad about her before X Factor. I said it could go EITHER way and it’s a really good career move for her because whatever happens, she’ll get some edge back and the public will get to see her in a way they haven’t in years. But of course you crazy Brit stans twisted it into something entirely different just to match your deranged views.

  • Chakra

    I can’t believe some of the stans still think she’s okay. Do you believe every piece of drivel Adam and Larry feed you? Probably. 

    I’m nervous for my good sis, tbh. :nailbites:

  • http://twitter.com/ICONI3 ICONI3

    Hmmm I wish her the best..I may watch to see how she acts lol. I always felt sorry for her…she reminds of Micheal Jackson in terms of the media being obsessed with her. I honestly think she just wants to stay home and take care of her kids,,,but we all know a lot on people depend of Britney to live(money wise).

  • http://twitter.com/Eclipse_9 Eclipse

    These shows have became lame & a waste of time tbh! its all about the judges now & less about the talented people that participate in it. i might just skip to the scenes that shows Godney talking,eating cheetos, saying nice,cool,i like it,oh wow etc etc . and thats pretty much it. Not here for that nobody lovato annoying/drama seeking girl. although the bitch has more personality than Godney. #shame

  • XF

    To those commenters who are in denial, stop making fucking excuses for her. Let’s be honest here; that Wendy Williams woman had it spot-on. Spears, when it all comes down to it, is a mess. Her recent performances have been lackluster, her music is phoned-in, she doesn’t sing, she doesn’t promote, all questions asked at her in interviews are pre-approved. You don’t even have to notice any of these things to come to the conclusion that she’s out of it; you just have to look at her eyes.

    Her team is partly to blame. It’s easy to say that they revived her career, that they care for her and that they know what is best for her. But if any of that is true, then why do they let her continue with her career at all, when it’s clear that her soul is not even in it, and when every lethargic performance she does only taints her legacy further. It’s pathetic how they saved her from her previous path, only to doom her to another.If Spears’ involvement on the X Factor is indeed an effort to rebuild her public image, then I hope and pray that she somehow nails this shit. Yeah, she’ll still get back some of her edge even if that doesn’t happen (as Prophet says) but the fact of the matter is that she NEEDS to pull this off. Not just to prove her critics wrong but also as a chance at redemption. Simon Cowell could give less of a fuck about how she does, he just knows she’ll bring in the number$

  • Jones

    this is making me sick. wait can’t people wait anymore? all those pseudo psychologist, yuck!

  • bonesnotsolovely

    well simon cowell got exactly what he wanted because even if someone has a meltdown on the show people are going to wach it, both women admitted that they would watch it now so in the end the ratings will probably be good and lets be honest thats all that really matters

  • animasaurus

    All I have to say is Britney is flawless and haters can GTFO tbh. She never should have signed up for this show though, Simon Cowell is an ass and the x factor is a pretty shit show.

  • themusicprophet

    Her stance is obviously nervous … But she’ll be completely fine … I don’t see a meltdown coming … The nerves are purely because she knows what everyone’s expecting

  • Arte

    I’m a Britney fan but I’m not deluded.
    You know why stans wanted her on Xfactor? Because we would see her on TV every week, and she would have good makeup and nice clothes and bla bla bla. Really? That’s all they care for? to have their “Britney fix”? It really makes me sick
    And if u say something like she looks nervous or unnatural, you are “buying the negative press” lol smh 

  • Popblock

    I love Britney to death, but I can’t deny the pictures. She has always gotten nervous before big things, and the way she is today just increase’s that anxiety ten folds.

    I do think this is something Britney really wants to do, AND something Larry and Adam are pushing her to achieve. It kills two birds with one stone; keeps Britney busy and potentially lays the groundwork for continued album/tour success.

    She just has to be herself and relax which is something I think she’s forgotten to do with the general public…. for better and worse.

  • iAmAwesome

    When will your faves make headline news for finger biting? NEVER!!! lol

    lol that is all I got from this. Britlexia 101

  • DRB

    Cares about Christina vs Britney

  • Briconic

    Well, I do bite my fingers, sometimes to the point that they bleed. It’s a nervous habit, but it doesn’t mean you’re coming unglued or are unstable. Nine times out of ten it’s a sign of oral fixation, and we all know Britney smokes. Plus, let’s face it…the pressure is on her in a big way right now, and this is the biggest thing she’s done in her career in years. It’s either going to ensure her continued success or sound the death knell for her career. Who wouldn’t be nervous?

    Just sayin’.

  • http://www.facebook.com/nightangel85 Kienya NightAngel Lockleer

    She knows that everyone is waiting for her to fail. Even her fans are because then they’ll finally have something to do other than eat Cheetos with Sean and Jayden ever since she’s gotten “better”. I don’t hope for the worse, but I won’t be surprised if she fails. Actually, I wouldn’t be surprised if she succeeds. Maybe this is all a stunt so she can sign a movie or book deal along with a new album and spin-off. Will I watch? No. I’ll just wait for the Yahoo articles.

  • Nicky

    “a worrying sign of nerves and anxiety.” or something she’s been doing for years and years. i’ve always bitten my nails and sometimes i accidentally do it to where they bleed. she’s been biting her nails forever so it’s really annoying to see everyone pointing it out in the media like it’s a sign that she’s unstable or something. it’s insane. that being said i’m still worried about x factor. she has months to prepare so that’s good. but i still don’t know if she can pull it off or not. terrified tbh

  • Chakra

    She’s not biting her nails though. She’s GNAWING on the edges of her fingers. Are you blind?

  • Nicky

    “probably even worse, than Monsters.” Um, no.

  • Nicky

    No one has said it was her idea……….. we don’t know what went on behind the scenes except that she got on the phone and said “I’m in. We’ve got a deal.” to Simon. And that doesn’t mean it was her idea.

  • http://twitter.com/HyunAKnowles HyunA Knowles

    Why there isn’t anyone mentioning/shading Demi? Bitch is sooo irrelevant to be in this show. At least Britney had some moments in her carreerk, she used to be the Pop Princess, while Demi still flopping here and there, struggling to get a hit on the charts.

  • Iceberg

    I clearly understand you proph. Even if I’m an Xtina fan, I like Britney as a person more than as an artist (though I still listen to How I Roll when everybody else was sleeping). You’re a true fan, and I wish Britney all the best

  • http://www.facebook.com/akie.koizora Akie Bertekad Cemerlang

    for better or worse, Simon really scored big with having Queen B on the show. too bad for Queen B. she is manipulated, again. but who knows maybe at some point on the show the true Britney will shine again. i have no doubt about that.

    ps: THIS IS ONCE AGAIN SHOWED HOW BRITNEY IS TRULY A LIVING ;LEGEND. SHE BITES HER FINGER NAILS AND IT IS NATION WIDE HEADLINE. ONLY BRITNEY. :)

  • Pingback: Adele Wins It All, With LMFAO Shufflin’ After At The 2012 Billboard Music Awards: Morning Mix | Music News, Reviews, and Gossip on Idolator.com

  • Justin

    Damn she looks really old, has awful skin and sounds like a drag queen. She is such a beautiful girl but that heavy smoking has finally caught up with her. I hope she quits and sees a dermatologist so she looks picture-perfect once the X Factor hits TV.

  • RockinJay

     
    So If Demi Lovato is so irrelevant then why are you talking about
    her in a public forum? I never understood this type of mentality. You
    call her “irrelevant” yet you still give her attention AND a
    career by giving her MORE public exposure? But you’re right. Demi
    Lovato is such a huge flop. Because all flops sign multi million
    dollar contracts to appear on public television right? Not to mention
    all flops have gold albums in South America, Platinum singles and
    successful south american world tours? Oh and lets not forget a very
    IRRELEVANT moment when she BEAT OUT Britney Spears FOR the people’s
    choice awards. Do you work this hard to be this stupid? Or does it
    just come naturally?

  • SilentRob

    “Why there isn’t anyone mentioning/shading Demi?”

    I guess you haven’t been to any other message boards aside from
    this one have you? You are quite the idiot you know?

    “Bitch is sooo irrelevant to be in this show.”Apparently she isn’t since she is ON the show for a 7 digit
    income. So yeah

    “At least Britney had some moments in her carreerk, she used to
    be the Pop Princess,”

    Oh please. Britney is and always has been considered an overrated
    hack who relies more on auto tune than her actual talent. At least
    Demi Lovato has a reputation for being an actual SINGER with a strong
    voice. You must be a very stupid teenager to think her “pop
    princess” status means that she has talent. Do you go to special
    schools?

    “while Demi still flopping here and there,”

    Obviously she’s not FLOPPING if she’s making a 7 digit income from
    this deal. Also I didn’t flops had platinum singles and gold albums
    internationally from overseas in south america. Nor was I aware that
    flops also have successful world tours. And as someone else pointed
    out, Flops don’t usually beat out the likes of britney spears, lady
    gaga and katy perry at people’s choice award shows.

    “struggling to get a hit on the charts.”

    My guess is that you haven’t SEEN the charts or radio requests as
    of late have you? You are quite the imbecile little girl. 

  • http://twitter.com/joeysauer Joey $auer

    She DOES look nervous. She’s tense as fuck in that picture up above and looks ridiculous. Don’t even try and tell me it’s a bad picture or “who wouldn’t be nervous”. Um, not me if I’d have had 10+ years in the business and couldn’t pose normally for a nice picture.

    God I wish her the best on the X Factor but the fact I even have to do so is worrying.

  • http://www.facebook.com/akie.koizora Akie Bertekad Cemerlang

    stay pressed being a basic bitch. the hype surrounding Demi’s only because she played that victim card. sooner people realize she was truly a bad bicth (punching someones face) and people just move on.