Sales Update: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly in 2011′s Top Pop Divas!

There’s nothing that stans love more than comparing the current record sales of their favorite pop divas and arguing about it until they’re blue in the face, so I went out and got an updated sales tally of the top pop tarts of 2011 so we can separate the fact from the fiction and find out just who has been a hot seller this year, and who’s headed straight for the bargain bin.

Adele, Beyonce, Britney, Rihanna, and Lady GaGa — all the ladies who released albums this year are here, and some of the results are just a teeny weeny bit shocking. One gal sold more than expected, one sold considerably less, and another one has been using inflated shipping figures to try and pass off a faux-Thriller sized smash!

So, without further ado…

Adele – 21 (released: January 19)

Surprise, surprise, Adele’s 21 is the biggest seller of 2011. Released back in January, Adelegend’s sophomore set has already sold an astonishing 14,349,000 copies worldwide, making it the biggest album since… God only knows. And with the holiday spending season currently in full effect, 21 will easily push past the 15 million mark in another week, and after that, the sky’s the limit. The album’s third single “Set Fire to the Rain” is only just now beginning to gain some serious steam on the charts, so there’s no telling how many copies 21 will end up pushing by the end of its run.

All this, and she hasn’t even promoted it in months.

Rihanna – Talk That Talk (released November 21)

There’s been a lot of carrying on about how Rihanna has yet to secure a No. 1 album in America, but with Talk That Talk’s current worldwide sales, it’s Rihanna who will be having the last laugh. In just a month, the disc has sold an impressive 1,303,000 copies, with the majority of the sales coming from outside of the US. It’s not like she’s doing bad in America, though — TTT may be under 400k in the States, but RiRi currently has the longest-running No. 1 single of 2011 over there with her smash hit “We Found Love”.

Sales of TTT will predictably slow down come January after the holiday season is over, but if the slow and steady success of Loud is anything to go by, TTT should reach the finish line as a winner as long as RiRi’s got some more hits up her sleeve to keep the momentum going.

Lady GaGa – Born This Way (released May 23)

GaGa and Interscope have been severely inflating the sales of Born this Way since it dropped.

With exaggerated shipping figures, they’ve tried to pass it off as selling upwards of 8 million copies worldwide, when in reality, the real number is 5,203,000 copies. Still, 5.2 milli is far from abysmal, putting Born This Way on par with Rihanna’s Loud (which also suffered inflated sales of 8 million from Rihanna’s label), but under the circumstances, I still consider Born This Way to be a bit of a flop.

First of all, when you minus the 440,000 copies that it sold from the 99 cent Amazon deal, the disc is technically at 4.8 million. Then take a look at the US sales — despite ‘selling’ 1.1 million copies first-week in the States, Born This Way has only just passed the 2 million mark, seven whole months later, and with the album’s fifth single “Marry The Night” fizzing on the charts, it isn’t likely that BTW is harboring any other big hits to propel the sales’ total much further.

Pretty disappointing for the heavily-promoted and self-proclaimed “greatest album of the decade” and follow-up to the 10-12 million-selling The Fame, don’t ya think?

Beyonce – 4 (released June 24)

Despite every effort under the sun to save this album, Beyonce needs to face the facts: 4 is a total flop. The hit-and-miss disc has only shifted about 1.95 million copies worldwide in six months, with approximately half of them coming straight outta the States. On top of that, Bey can’t even fall back on saying that it produced a hit single like Rihanna’s Rated R, because there simply hasn’t been any. Not to mention that the album was also overlooked at the Grammy Awards, only garnering a Best Rap/Sung collabo nod for “Party” with Andre 3000.

It wasn’t a lack of effort that caused 4 to tank, though. Bey’s promoted it everywhere from the Oprah finale to a headlining slot at Glastonbury, not to mention unveiling her pregnancy at the MTV VMAs while performing a track from the album. Then there were two TV concert specials — one in the UK, and one in the US — and music videos for almost every song on 4, but still nobody bought it.

Better luck next time, Bey.

Britney Spears – Femme Fatale (released March 28)

Britney’s Femme Fatale is my personal favorite on this list, but it’s by far been the biggest bomb of the bunch. In 9 months, the artificial collection of catchy tunes has only sold 1,450,000 copies worldwide, and with the Femme Fatale tour now over and the fourth single “Criminal” stalling on the Hot 100, the album’s future prospects aren’t good.

On the bright side, Femme Fatale has become Britney’s most successful album singles-wise to date. It’s the first in her career to produce three top ten hits on the Hot 100, and gave Brit her biggest radio hit ever. But it’s hardly a good thing when you transition from being an ‘albums artist’ to a singles one, is it?

This entry was posted on Thursday, December 22nd, 2011 at 7:33 pm and is filed under News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

  • Anonymous

    It’s surprising me that people are shocked that Beyonce’s album and all of her singles flopped? I knew it was going to happen. I figured she would go to number 1 then decline. She’ll flop next year too (yes she will put out an album next year). The only thing that shocked me was Adele slaying the industry and Lady Gaga not lol! I really hope Britney takes a long break, like a FEW years. Then she can come back strong. If Beyonce actually takes a break (because she has never done it) then she can come back strong. The music on 4 wasn’t the problem, it was her over saturation which is actually good news. But sadly I’d be willing to put money on the fact that she will put an album out sometime next year. Rihanna, *sighs*…. I don’t have the energy. This was the first Rihanna album I bought and I’m already done with it. She’ll take a break after this album.

  • Yumm

    Femme Fatale is by far the best of the bunch, the big problem is she did hardly any promo she only did 3 days starting the day of it’s release and she released it in the first quarter which is when music sales are at their lowest. If she had done Circus era promo and released it in November the album would be much more successful.

  • Aryo

    21 is one of my least favorite records released this year, so i guess i have to disagree with knowing it as good as femme fatale! lol, but u kno thats just my opinion lol

  • DRB

    13 years in, Britney shouldn’t be told what to do. And if she wants to make HER record, let her.

  • http://twitter.com/Mrhollyw00dfam3 Jonatan Mejia

    So true I remember when Proph wrote that post last year anticiatpion list lol

  • Anonymous

    It’s Killer Love >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Aryo! How could you?! HAHA jk.

    21 > Femme Fatale > TTT + BTW + 4. I don’t understand how anybody could dislike 21. It was a refreshing and unexpected album.

  • http://twitter.com/Andy4B Andy4B

    I love this post!

    As prophet stated, this would be my favs as well: Femme Fatale + 21 >>>>>>> 4 + TTT + BTW all equally mediocre.

    As for Femme Fatale being a flop sales wise, I think it still did pretty amazing if you see the promotion she did for the album, which was basically nothing. Bitch started promoting the week the album came out, and before that nobody even knew she had an album coming, except people on Twitter lol.

    Im glad she had an amazing tour though. I was in the train last week and told my friend I went to Britney and he was like, does she have new music? The last thing I heard from her was the Circus Tour…

    BTW dis amazing, but it should be considered a flop seeing the promo she did and how she promised it be the best album of the decade.

    21 by Adele is simply amazing, there is no doubt about that. That’s an album full of quality songs and Adele deserves every success she got.

    And don’t get me started on TTT and 4, cause let’s say that will hurt some stabs…

  • Anonymous

    Lol no. Rihanna needs to go away for a while just like everyone else. She needs to take her tired ass to bed and sleep for about 2 years, and then make a truly worthwhile album because Talk That Talk was incredibly disappointing. Even if Britney’s album wasn’t necessarily her own vision at least she put out one of the best damn pop albums of the year. Rihanna? Not so much.

  • Frankie

    Beyonce has officially confirmed she is gna start doing a star is born mid next year and is currently in the studio working on the soundtrack (I duno where the new album rumors started) bey always spreads them out ..DIL (june 2003), bday (september 2006), sasha fierce (november 2008 ), 4 (june 2011) .. She usually tours inbetween like most other artists do (well those that can tour) .. Where do u get ur beyonce info, everytime I read something u right about her I’m confused like are we talking about the same person?? LOL agree with ur britney and rihanna comments tho

  • ChristinasCOMING

    For Gaga’s sake, if you cannot sell an album honestly then that proves just how irrelevant and for the moment you really are.

    Do you honestly think if Gaga had released any other song as the first single, BTW would’ve still sold like it did in it’s first week? IDTS! Look how quickly it slid down the chart in the weeks following it’s release.

    I believe that if Britney really took a break from the spotlight and relaxed and lived a normal life, she has the power to come back and give us the old Britney I know I love.

    As for Beyonce, she needs to sit her ass down for a while. She just seems like she doesn’t like sharing the spotlight with other females.

    As for Rihanna….it’s like watching paint dry with her!

  • ChristinasCOMING

    She shouldn’t be told what to do but if she’d never had that meltdown, she would’ve never been placed under a damn conversatorship. It did save her life and career but at the same time, she’s like a 30 year old kid. She doesn’t have custody of her kids, she’s dope up on medication, and about to go for her 3rd marriage in less than 10 years.

  • BL

    This.

    I want Britney to make the music she wants but lets not be delisional here- she is 8 years out from her ballad masterpiece “Everytime”. Things change- the times, her voice, her writing style, etc. But rest assured that Britney could record herself pooping and I’d buy it- she is three years older than me and I have worshipped at her altar since I first saw BOMT on MTV when it premiered.
    As for why FF has horrible sales… She had three HOT singles but maybe people were afraid to buy the album because they knew so little about it. I don’t know but I do think that Brit has a lot to be proud of in regards to the success of TTW (the song is amazing). It is hard to have the success she has had and be able to stay relevant (which she has despite what the album numbers are)

    Beyonce’s stans will always give her HUGE first week numbers so I am not impressed. I loved 4 but Beyonce is a terrible person and needed to be knocked down some- bitch thinks she got the game all locked up and this era proved that its not the case.

    Rihanna- I love her (and TTT) but I do not get the lack of album sales… Its weird. If she would have debuted a few years earlier than maybe she wouldn’t have to work so damn hard. I worry about my Riri and her health. The industry has put so many demands on her :(

    Adele sold big bc old people like her and old people still by CD’s

    LG- BTW was an uneven body of work and I am glad I ony paid .99 for the album.

    In the end I dont care about album sales- the artists REAL profits come from touring so support your fave and go see the live and buy a t-shirt while you are there.

  • Anonymous

    Well I’m not exactly sure what you mean by “Where do u get ur beyonce info, everytime I read something u right about her I’m confused like are we talking about the same person??” because this is the first time I have ever put any “Beyonce info” in a comment and apparently I was wrong. It’s always been my opinion. We have just had conflicting opinions that’s all. But I think I’m going to stick with my belief that she will put a studio album out next year when this “Star is Born” fiasco doesn’t go well by no fault of Beyonce’s. I’m just saying I really don’t think that particular movie will do well in 2012. Again that is obviously my opinion.

  • DRB

    No, I bought my own and then my hoe bought me another copy months later (due to assuming I didn’t have a physical copy)

  • DRB

    A flop is also a flop. Regardless of why. The era was a success but the album is not.

  • Aryo

    hahaha, of course KILLER LOVE is the best, but i just compared the ones that were mentioned on this post :)

  • http://twitter.com/ThatBoyLuke luke Marriott

    Maybe she wouldn’t have had a breakdown in the first place if she’d been given more freedom in her career and personal life.

  • http://twitter.com/ThatBoyLuke luke Marriott

    Maybe if she’d been out promoting her ass off like Beyonce and Gaga but Britney hasn’t properly promoted an album since “In the zone” and people can tell she doesn’t have her heart in it atm, she’s just going through the motions because she has too.

  • http://twitter.com/ThatBoyLuke luke Marriott

    Adele is proof that albums can still sell in great numbers IF you put something out that’s unique and resonates with a lot of people, the same happened with Amy’s “Back to black”, SUBO’s “I Dreamed a dream” etc…
    Maybe if more artists stopped following the trends and worked on something different then more people would but their albums.

    Britney’s heart isn’t in it, everyone can tell and she did like ZERO promotion so it’s no supprise that she sold less, her label need to let her grow as an artist and put more mature music out like she wants too, do you think Madonna would be where she is if Warner had made her release the same kind of songs as “Papa dont preach” for her entire career???

    Bey has flopped because she doesn’t have her father pulling the strings pure and simple, she is a stupid person who got so big she thought she could do everything herself and she can’t.

    Gaga has been on a slide since “TFM” and she’s always inflating her figures and it’s lame, “BTW” is a crap album and she’s a crap artist.

    Rihanna sells well (5m average) so people really should get off herback, I prefer “Loud” to “TTT” but no doubt it’ll do well in the end and whats with all ther fuss over her not selling huge in the US??? she isnn’t American she’s BAJAN how many Bajans are selling 1.6m in a foreign country?!

  • http://www.facebook.com/ithar.adel Ithar Adel

    Who is the loser of the year?
    Check it out on your new favorite german blog ibreathepop!
    http://ibreathepop.blogspot.com/2011/12/popjahr-2011-die-verlierer-des-jahres.html#more

  • BigBang4Real

    Nobody cares about charts tbh.

    4 is better than those albums, 21 is a close second, and that’s what matters. (at least to me)

  • MusicStan

    beyonce is a terrible person?? wait how long have u guys been friends?? cuz i kno u cant be basing that off of what u read on blogs and in the media HAHA come on ppl we cant be so naive we dnt kno these ppl anymore than strangers .. u said u like 4 well thats the real extent of ur relationship with her

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=715158581 Michael Curd

    To be quite honest, I don’t think ANY of these albums are good. In fact, I could rank them in order of awfulness:
    1. Lady Gaga – Born This Way
    2. Britney Spears – Femme Fatale
    3. Rihanna – Talk That Talk
    4. Adele – 21
    5. Beyoncé – 4
    I even surprised myself that I put 4 as the least suckiest of the lot, but that just shows how bad I feel the rest are lol.

    I’m actually really proud of my girl Avril Lavigne for being the 2nd highest selling non-Japanese artist in Japan in 2011, behind Lady Gaga. ‘Goodbye Lullaby’ was such an underrated album, and did not receive the recognition and success it deserved (I blame the terrible single choices and complete lack of belief in the record by her now EX record company RCA, the bastards). If only the single choices had gone something like – What The Hell, Wish You Were Here, Stop Standing There and then Smile then I think people would’ve been more clear on the overall feel of the album. All the same, I’m very proud of what the album’s achieved under the circumstances :)

  • Faithz

    Great  Read  and  sound  great  and  true  to
    the  Cause  for  2011.

  • Faithz

    Often  time  i  just  wonder  why  those  who  have  made  a  
    great  Career  out  of  Doing  Music  do  not  relax  from  time
    to  time  and  enjoy  the  Fruits  of  their  Labor.  But  then  again
    i  guess  its  always  all  about  that  almighty dollar  bill.

  • Speoples18@gmail.com

    Idk why ppl hate TTT so much..Roc me out and Farewell I cud have done without. But I like the rest. Its fun and puts me in a good mood. To each his own I guess. Merry Christmas guys! Or Happy Haunaka (spelling sorry)..Kwanzaa..orwhatever u celebrate! = D

  • Jj201093

    Umm..do u know Beyonce personally? If not, take it from her peers. There’s proof of pretty much EVERY CELEB in the music industry (past and present) including your fave (unless your fave is Keri Hilson) saying that Beyonce is one of the nicest and most genuine celebs they’ve ever met. Soooo my question is………Is this Keri in disguise?

  • The Real Facts

    I have to laugh at the pathetic people claiming that Gaga’s sales are inflated while at the same time accepting Adele’s ridiculously high numbers as fact.  It just confirms the stupidity of people.  To those who don’t already know this let me explain it to you -the numbers on Billboard’s charts are not true sales counts. 

    Adele’s sales numbers are a scandal waiting to happen.  21 did not sell anywhere near the numbers being reported.  I would be surprised if the actual sales were even half of what is being reported.  I’m amazed that people think the numbers reported by Billboard are the actual number of SALES.  They are not.  Soundscan (Billboard’s sales tracking company) just counts the number of times a CD is scanned and a CD does not have to be sold to be scanned.  The British music industry and media have been backing Adele and it is crystal clear that they are manipulating the sales numbers.  Just look at the chart history.  Even the most successful albums have a chart cycle of going to the top then slowly dropping down and then staying in the lower levels of the charts for several months or even years.  But four or five times 21 dropped to #3 or #5 only to bounce right back to #1 the following week.  That is something that has happened only a few times in the history of the Billboard charts and yet people really believe that it happened several times with 21?  Really?

    On the other hand, Gaga’s management closely tracks the actual number of downloads and real sales including promotional sales.  That is very important because while Billboard does use Soundscan’s very easily manipulated numbers, they don’t count actual promotional sales (that’s when the CD is packaged with another product).  Gaga’s team is more interested in knowing the real number of people that got the album into their hands.  And that is why her manager states a higher number than what Billboard counts.

    As a side note – a great big thanks to all the pathetic Gaga haters who are responsible for Amazon raising the price of their daily album download special.  Each day Amazon puts an mp3 album on sale and they used to charge $1.99 but now they charge $3.99 for it.  Why the increase you ask?  Well, you see back in May Amazon wanted to promote their new Cloud service and they knew Gaga’s new CD would generate a lot of first day sales so they decided to take a loss and sell it for $0.99 for one day.  Let me repeat that for you idiots – AMAZON DECIDED TO SELL IT FOR $0.99.  NOT GAGA OR GAGA’S TEAM.  IT WAS AMAZON’S IDEA. When asked about it later Gaga said she thought $0.99 was about what a digital download should cost.  But, of course, the pathetic haters had to have a whining, crying, hissy fit and go on to bitch and moan for months about the approximately 400,000 (a small amount overall) sold at $0.99.  So what happened?  Well, Billboard finally caved in and changed  their policy and set the minimum price of $3.49 for a sale to count on their charts.  Now, I’m not really sure where Billboard gets off deciding what the minimum price of digital downloads will be but I don’t blame them.  No, I blame you pathetic losers who whined and whined incessantly about it. 

    So now we will never get a digital download for less than $3.49.  Way to go losers.

  • TheAnalyst

    Always that negative spin on Britney. Glad you’re not a fan anymore.

  • TalkThatFatality

    Talk that Talk and Femme Fatale are my favourite, Born This Way comes in second (I like 12 tracks off the 17 track album) and 4 I just don’t care for

  • Anonymous

    1. Still a fan
    2. Negative spin? I said it was my favorite album out of every single one listed here. She sold 1.45 million. It’s a fact you delusional nut job. That’s a fact. My God. 

    Britney stans are the WORST. I now rate them on the same level as monsters and Bey stans. SMH. All sick people who need help to stop these unhealthy and obsessive fixations. 

  • Anonymous

    Can i just say that Britney is still doing her thing! Femme Fatale is one of her best albums to date. It is more unique and different than all her others! People say that she doesn’t still have it but at least she still gives all that she still has. Honestly, how much fire would you still have if you went through all that she did? Then she just bounced back with the vengeance that is Blackout! She’s not like a Mariah Carey whose idea of dancing is moving her arms and walking. Britney is still a great performer and if you go to any of her concerts, thats what you’ll get, a fierce performance from the queen of pop. As for Adele, her songs get catchy and i find myself singing them quite often but thats cause they’re ALWAYS playing! If it wasn’t for them always playing, i probably wouldn’t listen to them because i find her music a little boring just cause  like something i can dance to! Talk That Talk has actually been my favorite Rihanna album since Good Girl Gone Bad. With tracks like WFL,TTT,WHYB,RMO,&RL that i find really good.(Those are the only ones i like). Theres just nothing i have to say about 4. I took a quick listen when i came out and never had the urge to go back again. As for miss Gaga. I was a dedicated monster the day Just Dance was releases. I was at the Monster Ball with a bold on my cheek and everything, singing along the album that i LOVED PASSIONATELY called The Fame & dancing along to the songs i loved from TFM. Then came BTW. That album is complete crap. Ive never had an artist that i once loved, release an album i didnt enjoy at all. For me, BTW and Gaga is just that. I Have no idea where she went wrong really, was it that horrid Album Artwork? That mediocre first single, Born This Way & all the singles to follow? Im just really ready for BTW to be an album of my past and just hope she finds that fun, dance in my underwear music i once loved. Ahh that was like a nice therapy session for me :)

  • Emmanuelirabor

    This is false this dumb skull is lieing about beyonce what about katy perry you left her out putting rihanna you are so dumb you big useless liar.
    The person is rihanna stan who do not like beyonce but foolishly of you we are always there for the queen you bastard

  • Quotes

    The list is correct that you meds and shut all the way up.

  • Gorkem

    What is the problem with the sales of Britney? She is around for almost 15 years and she is already one of top 5 biggest selling females ever and the biggest selling of the decade. She has nothing to do anymore.. She does not even promote but still can sell 1.5 millions which is a success for today’s record industry where people do not buy albums anymore.. (Adele is an extreme surprise) Britney’s non-promoted 7th album sells 1.5 millions whereas Gaga’s freaky-promoted second one sells just 5 millions.. Gaga is a failure.. Not Britney!