B.A.P Make Their Best Comeback To Date, Rainbow Do Not

B.A.P One Shot Rainbow Tell Me

After going through a K-pop drought that lasted several agonizing days, we’ve suddenly gotten comebacks from B.A.P, Rainbow, and even NU’EST, who finally managed to release a song that doesn’t suck. But while NU’EST’s new single is quite good, B.A.P’s is freakin’ awesome.

After pulling a “Shy Boy” on the deliriously addictive “Stop It,” B.A.P have returned to their aggressive bad boy image and the quaking hip-hop sound of “Warrior.” Their new single, “One Shot,” is huge and heavy, with a hook that sounds like it was custom-made a sports commercial. It’s an anthem, like all the drama, angst, and swag of the group’s previous singles has been crammed in together to create the ultimate B.A.P hit.

The blockbuster music video takes a page from T-ara’s gun totin’ “Cry Cry” and “Lovey-Dovey” mini-dramas, with a complicated plot that features plenty of violence and a twist ending. TS Entertainment reportedly spent over $900,000 on it, and you can tell; it’s a movie quality music video. The slick quality is most appreciated when my boo Bang Yong Guk wears a tank top, revealing his flawless twig arms that I want around me, ASAP.

And obviously, with this being a B.A.P video, the choreography is off the chain. I don’t know how these guys have been doing all this hardcore shit for over 12 months straight and not broken something or died from exhaustion.

So fucking good.

After praising B.A.P to the high heavens, I now have to semi-drag Rainbow — a group I was really rooting for.

Last month I wrote a piece for Popdust about how badly Rainbow have been mismanaged throughout their career, and that they better pull out something seriously amazing for their first K-pop comeback in over a year-and-a-half. And yeah, they totally didn’t. Their long-awaited comeback single, “Tell Me Tell Me,” is a bubbly slice of K-pop that could easily pass as an AOA single. It’s not bad, and the cute concept actually suits Rainbow more than some of their old sexy concepts did, but again, the whole thing is no better or worse than any AOA single. That might be acceptable for some groups, but it isn’t for Rainbow. These are the same girls who released “A” and “Mach”, easily two of the most mesmerizing pop singles of the past five years. Even “To Me,” which could never possibly live up to the perfection of Rainbow’s work with Sweetune, was still an utter knockout.

“Tell Me Tell Me” could be forgiven if Rainbow were making three comebacks a year and wanted to switch things up by trying something cute, but it’s not okay for them to return with something this innocuous after so long out of the spotlight. I mean, “Candy Girls” was better than this, and that wasn’t even released as a real single.

Since Rainbow’s new album, Rainbow Syndrome, is apparently just part one of something bigger, we can only hope that “Tell Me Tell Me” is just a warm-up before they bring out the big guns on their next single. If not, DSP needs to just forget it and give us the saucy Sweetune-produced Jaekyung solo debut that K-poppers everywhere have been waiting years for.

This entry was posted on Wednesday, February 13th, 2013 at 5:46 am and is filed under Music Videos, New Music, News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

  • http://twitter.com/kpop_forthewin alex cooper

    I agree with Rainbow. It’s a nice track – but not for the only remaining 2009 group to not win an award on music shows. Although I feel Korea will like this. I still think they are going to have this as the warm up, getting the attention, then release a part 2 in a month or so which brings in the sales!

  • theprophetblog

    I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s the plan. It’s the only explanation for this song other than DSP is retarded. It’s doing shitty on Instiz so far though. I don’t think I’ve seen it higher than 27 yet. Nine Muses “Dolls” got off to a way stronger start.

  • a_chan

    Rainbow Syndrome part 2′s title track should have a drastically different sound to “Tell Me Tell Me”. So far DSP is copying Younha’s strategy for her 3rd album both in concept and in execution. I’m guessing/hoping that what they’re trying to do is rebuild momentum before coming back with a career saving song. They’ve tried coming back guns blazing from a long hiatus before with “A” and what should have been a mega hit was barely top 10. This hiatus has been even longer. It’s a safe decision, if a bit boring.

  • jp

    I had a love/hate relationship with Rainbow ever since they hit the scene with GhostshipGal.
    I mean sometimes I feel like they are lacking something… special… they could have used a better mainvocal maybe? and too many filler members :(

  • http://www.facebook.com/akie.koizora Akie Bertekad Cemerlang

    IMO, BAP’s OneShot is up there with BigBang’s Haru Haru, T-ara’s Day by Day, Mblaq’s This Is War, K.Will’s Please Don’t, and Davichii’s Don’t Say Goodbye as the best music videos/shirt films out of K-Pop history.

  • animasaurus

    These are NOT the bad ass girls of Rainbow that created fierce songs like “A” “to me” and “so cool” (not sistar’s). WTF is the dancing and those outfits. I still love them but I feel like DSP just gave up on them, my only hope now is that their next single is as good as this one is bad since it’s supposed to be the opposite of this concept.

    As for BAP, “One Shot” like all of their other songs (although I love “power”) is missing something. Their songs lack oomph and aren’t memorable imo. They are so gorgeous and talented, hope they get that breakout hit and prove me wrong with a better and more worthwhile song.

  • Woorier

    Who the heck is going around downvoting all the comments that criticize Rainbow? Look, I love the group and think Woori’s one of the best female idol rappers, but this song was awful.

  • duper

    Trying so hard not to sound like a delusional sone, but tell me tell me concept feels like second-grade gee+igab. But the song’s kinda okay though…

  • theprophetblog

    I agree, I noticed it too

  • Guest

    Lamebow is shit

  • my self

    I seriously think the male groups this year will be out doing female groups. b.a,p comeback is just amazing and actually well throughout. Rainbow isn’t bad but so damn boring and typical. i feel only female groups that will stand out is sistar 19 and SNSD.

  • http://twitter.com/SuzySooyoung Suzy Sooyoung

    Look. Rainbow’s single is def a lackluster when u compare everything they teased BUT it now grew on me and I think it’s kinda of cute THO forgetable. I really hope this is the start of something bigger to come or they’re done LOL

    As fo BAP I dont really feel this song atm but it might grow on me. Their last single “Stop It” tho is ICONIC lol

  • http://twitter.com/ReedLive Reed Livengood

    I, for one, kind of like Tell Me Tell Me. I think it’s a rather mature cutesy sound, mostly due to the girls’ very solid vocals.
    It’s a far cry from the flawless A and Mach, but I can deal with this.

  • Laurence Nope

    This Rainbow comeback is especially frustrating because the other songs on the album range from good to fantastic (and you should give it a listen Proph). They literally made the worst possible choice for the single. Imagine if they had come back with the epic space disco of Cosmic Girl, with a music video that’s a cross between Seo In Young’s Let’s Dance and Momoiro Clover Z’s Bodacious Space Symphony 7th Movement Infinite Love. And then there’s track 5, which sounds like Lee Min Soo doing his best Sweetune imitation for an IU song. But instead DSP decides to go with the album’s most generic song along with a cheap generic video? I know that the company that manages Korea’s second most lucrative girl group must have the resources to at least pretend to care about Rainbow. Why do they insist on putting all their eggs in one basket?

  • t-errorist

    Cosmic Girl is so much better than Tell Me Tell Me. Should have been the single.

  • tjoz

    Was going for Rainbow this time around hoping that I would see another Mach and also going off that Woori rap teaser. Was expecting some mid 90′s sound just off that alone; sort of what Azelia Banks would do with out the language. Its bit of a let down.

    Hopefully on the second half of the mini album we get something close to Woori’s teaser complete with black and white MV. Rainbow are at their best when its with a live sound; they are the group form of Amerie.

    The packaging better be good on it; DSP are known to be stingy mf’s when it comes to physical releases. Ive already brought it.. At least I got Jisook and Woori pictures to look forward to in it.

  • Takamina

    I actually really like this song, weirdly enough. I kind of like how they’re singing all aegyo against a kind of aggressive beat. I agree it’s not unique enough to give them a real comeback though.

  • http://twitter.com/Ieejihyun phil

    it’s in the top 10 rn

  • http://twitter.com/cbisquitaz Courtney Smith

    I just realized that the “Cosmic Girl” sounds awfully like Serebro’s “Mama Lover” especially on the chorus. The melody is almost exactly the same and they both have that funky disco pop :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ivy-Shy/100002731160332 Ivy Shy

    Everyone’s free to have their own opinions even extremely strong positions, but at least you should look into some facts first before over generalizing. Rainbow was due to make a comeback last summer but that got shelved due to Hyunyoung’s surgery which prevented her from singing for half a year. It wasn’t due to whatever other reasons many speculated about. As for this song, it’s much better than the latest couple snsd trash singles which deaf but not blind lemmings still found a way to twist positively. Of course, just my opinion.